Invest in Brazil Invest in Brazil: The Hazards of Familiarity by Eric J. Fry The Rude Awakening Wall Street, New York Thursday, December 8, 2005 Eric Fry explains why, given a choice between investing in GM or Brazil, you should Invest in Brazil. ------------------------- - GM versus Brazil – your front row seat for the
middleweight smack down,
- The eventual contempt of familiarity and the stages
beforehand and,
- Not nearly enough about Brazilian bikinis
------------------------- [Joel's Note: Below, Eric pits junky GM bonds against the emerging market of Brazil. Aside from boasting the world's skimpiest bikinis, Brazil also finds itself in possession of a fairly robust economy...at least one growing TOWARDS robust anyway. Before you read on, however, you might want to take a look at the investment alert sent out late yesterday afternoon. Addison Wiggin, our publisher, has recently announced the reopening of the Agora Financial Reserve doors. The price on this select, lifetime service is going to shoot up on Jan 1 and there is bound to be a holiday rush before then. You would do well to check it out here before the stampede. http://www.agora-inc.com/reports/AFR/EAFRFC02 As always, you can email any comments, complaints, suggestions or anything else Rude related to me here at aussiejoel@the-rude-awakening.com Now, back to those Brazilian bikinis... I mean bonds... --- Advertisement --- Double Your Money at LEAST 12 Times in 12 Months I'm going to introduce you to the man, who very well could be your profiting hero. A man who out of 35 picks in 2004, walked away with 31 winners... And 5 of them could have tripled every dollar invested. His name is Steve Sarnoff... known as one of the most aggressive and successful options experts on the planet. Options are an exceptional way to make money in volatile markets. Whether the market goes up or down makes no difference... as long as there is movement, there are profits to be had. Let Steve show you step by step how you too could be soaking up gains of astonishing percentages... like 898%... 529%... even 1,202%. Altogether, it won't take more than about three minutes a week... http://www.agora-inc.com/reports/OHL/EOHLFC03 ------------------------- The Hazards of Familiarity By Eric J. Fry Familiarity breeds contempt...but not right away. In the beginning, familiarity breeds desire, when then becomes mere comfort, then only tolerance, then resignation...and THEN contempt. Most U.S. bond investors appear to have entered the comfort/tolerance phase. We predict they will arrive at the contempt phase...eventually. But for now, most bond investors prefer familiar, high-risk bonds to unfamiliar, lower-risk bonds. As recently as last February, for example, bond buyers readily accepted a 5.6% yield on the 3-year paper of General Motors. We were amazed. In the February 11 edition of the Rude Awakening we observed, "GM's debt load is massive and growing. Its net debt outstanding has doubled over the last four years to $244 billion. In addition, GM's balance sheet contains a towering pension liability of $102.4 billion and a $67.5 billion liability for other post-employment benefits (OPEB), primarily health care, insurance and other benefits that the company is committed to providing both current retires and active employees. These already-considerable costs seem certain to grow...Net-net, GM seems fully deserving of its 'near junk' rating and seems likely to trend from bad to worse." In other words, GM's tenuous financial health was no secret last February. And yet, investors continued to bid for GM bonds, even after the company fell into the ranks of junk credits. (To be sure, the buyers of GM bonds have been demanding ever higher rates of interest over the last several months. But they still buy, nonetheless). Meanwhile, the Brazilian government's 3-year notes have gone begging. Unfamiliarity, tinged with suspicion, is to blame. Invest in Brazil: "Brazil is not GM" "Brazil is not GM," some might protest. To which we would reply, "Thank goodness." Brazil, despite its considerable foibles, runs a trade surplus and only a very slight government deficit. It also boasts the world's strongest currency over the last three years. GM, for its part, is merely familiar. The teetering auto giant has managed to attract buyers to its bonds, based on what it has been...NOT on what it threatens to become. Throughout the last year, the Rude Awakening has continuously spurned GM's stock and bonds, while simultaneously extolling the virtues of certain Brazilian investments. We have not been blind to either GM's storied past, nor to Brazil's checked economic history. But we simply believed that the relative pricing of GM and Brazilian bonds was way out of whack. We still do, though less out of whack than 10 months ago. 
On March 25, for example, Brazilian 3-year notes paid an 18.1% rate of interest, while GM 3-years paid only 6.5%. Today, Brazilian 3-years yield a still-hefty 16.5%, while GM 3-years yield a nearly identical 16.2%. Which one is the better credit; the fatally-indebted auto giant or the resurgent South American economy? The question answers itself...GM is skidding toward bankruptcy, while Brazil is lurching toward financial respectability. Until recently, however, General Motors' lengthy history of success – it was the first American corporation to earn $1 billion in one year, for example – protected it from exacting credit analysis. Bond-buyers turned a blind eye to its questionable health and blithely assumed that GM's past would faintly resemble its future. On the flip-side, bond investors have shunned Brazilian debt. The country's considerable recent successes have not yet erased its legacy of serial currency and debt crises. So even if the country's resource-based economy is flourishing for the moment, the memory of catastrophic failure is too fresh to encourage bond-buying. Sign Up for The Rude Awakening Start your mornings off with a dose of Rude news. The Rude Awakening is dedicated to highlighting phenomena in the financial markets that others may not see. Let the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times "break news." Sign up FREE Today! We will not share your email address with anyone else, period. -Andrew Palmer, Director E-commerce Marketing We Value Your Privacy |
Invest in Brazil: Familiarity Becomes Contempt
But we suspect that the world is changing, and that we may no longer trust assumptions from the past to guide investments in the future. For your editors here at the Rude Awakening, GM's familiarity has already reached the contempt phase...We would not wish the automaker's bonds on the North Koreans. Indeed, generally speaking, we would spurn all US high- yield debt in favor of foreign sovereign debt. Both are risky; but we would prefer the risk of holding bonds from unfamiliar, but increasingly credit-worthy, foreign governments to the risk of holding familiar U.S. junk bonds. "When the Banana Republic countries can borrow at single- digit interest rates, it means investors have no fear," Steve Sjuggerud recently observed. "Right now, the lack of fear in emerging markets (based on emerging market interest rates compared to U.S. interest rates) is literally off the charts. "As a group right now, emerging market countries can borrow for the long term at an average interest rate of 6.8%. This is ludicrous, and a record low level. 2.4 percentage points above U.S. Treasury interest rates is the record, and it's where we are now. 
"Why's this so important? Only twice in history have emerging market countries ever been able to borrow at less than 4 percentage points above U.S. Treasury interest rates... early 1994 and mid-1997. Immediately following both of those cases, stocks in emerging markets were absolutely obliterated. "An average investor in those markets ('94 and '97-'98) probably lost over half their money in both instances. Here we are again, where emerging market countries can borrow at 4 percentage points over Treasury rates or less." Invest in Brazil: Double Sell We would not quarrel with Dr. Sjuggerud's observation, but we would add two qualifications. 1) The narrowing of spreads between Treasurys and emerging market debt may be saying as much about the deteriorating credit-quality of the U.S. government as it does about the improving credit- quality of emerging markets. But that's a topic for another day; 2) If emerging market bonds are a sell, U.S. junk bonds are a "double sell." Just as Brazilian 3-years represent a more compelling opportunity than GM 3-years, so too, we believe, do emerging market government bonds offer a better opportunity than U.S. junk bonds. To frame the comparison, let's consider two NYSE-traded closed end funds: the Salomon Brothers Emerging Market Income Fund II (NYSE: EDF) and the RMK High Income Fund (NYSE: RMH). RMH holds BB-rated (junk) bonds from US issuers; EDF holds BB+-rated government bonds from emerging markets. RMK pays 10% per annum; EDF pays 8%. (most of the difference in yields results from the fact that RMH applies more leverage to its portfolio than EDF.) On the surface, therefore, both investments seem roughly comparable. But if we dig a little deeper, key fundamental differences emerge. RMH's top ten holdings include the junk-rated bonds of airline-leasing companies, mortgage-lenders and manufactured-home financers. By contrast, Brazilian government bonds represent 22% of EDF's portfolio, while Mexican bonds represent 21%. No doubt, RMH and EDF both hold risky bonds. But we'd rather buy into the unfamiliar risk of growing foreign economies than the familiar risk of troubled U.S. industries. In short, familiarity is overpriced. [Joel's Note: If your investments are begging for a vacation, maybe somewhere warm and away from the blistering cold of Wall Street, you could well benefit from the insight of the worlds greatest living economist, Dr. Richebacher. See what the good Doctor has to say right here: The Richebacher Letter www.agora-inc.com/reports/RCH/ERCHFB05/ --- Advertisement --- The One Simple Secret That Will Guarantee Your Child... $25,000 by Age 13... $60,000 by Age 18 $500,000 by Age 32 $1 million by Age 38 $9.3 Million by Age 55... ... And Will Likely Put an Extra Million or More in Your Pocket, Too. http://www.agora-inc.com/reports/400SSEEDS/E400FC06 ------------------------- And the Markets... | Wednesday | Tuesday | This week | Year-to-Date | DOW | 10,811 | 10,857 | -67 | 0.3% | S&P | 1,257 | 1,264 | -8 | 3.8% | NASDAQ | 2,252 | 2,261 | -21 | 3.5% | 10-year Treasury | 4.52 | 4.49 | 0.00 | 4.48 | 30-year Treasury | 4.72 | 4.69 | 0.00 | 4.67 | Russell 2000 | 683 | 688 | -8 | 4.8% | Gold | $515.30 | $510.90 | $11.93 | 17.8% | Silver | $8.81 | $8.72 | $0.25 | 29.3% | CRB | 324.66 | 324.29 | 1.28 | 14.3% | WTI NYMEX CRUDE | $59.33 | $60.08 | $0.01 | 36.5% | Yen (YEN/USD) | JPY 121.02 | JPY 120.81 | -0.48 | -18.0% | Dollar (USD/EUR) | $1.1721 | $1.1791 | -6 | 13.5% | Dollar (USD/GBP) | $1.7353 | $1.7417 | -21 | 9.5% |
|