Fear and Complacency Fear and Complacency: "Free Diving" Isn't Free by Eric J. Fry The Rude Awakening Wall Street, New York Tuesday, February 7, 2006 Eric Fry notices and wonders about the low levels of Fear and the high Complacency present in the markets. ------------------------- - When you can see the razor sharp reef just a few
feet below your speeding board...it's a good time to think about risk management,
- Has volatility gone on vacation? Or is she just
hiding behind her smoky index? And,
- Sewing circles and stamp collections, still
unpopular with suicide bombers...
------------------------- Joel Bowman, reporting from New York, a world away from the warm waters of Indonesia... When you take off on a wave over a reef break, there exists a kind of caution in your action that is totally absent when paddling into a wave over a sand break. It is not just the difference in the formation of the wave, more the difference in what happens to you if you fall off and hit what's underneath it. The scrapes and bumps of a sand wipeout are nothing compared to being torn up by jagged reef. Everyone remembers the first time they graduate to a reef break as a young surfer. There is a rush of excitement fueled by the knowledge that danger lurks but a few feet below your speeding board. Even clearer than the memory of your first surf over reef is the first time you actually hit it's razor edges... My first scare occurred on a surf trip with my dad in Indonesia when I was ten years old. I had been growing more and more confident in the water, paddling onto larger waves and taking off further inside, where the face of the wave is steeper and the risk of coming unstuck is greater. After a few hours in the water I felt it was time to take on one of the larger "set" waves. As soon as I felt the power of the larger wave beneath my board, I knew I was in over my head. Suddenly, the reef below the glistening Balinese water didn't look so peaceful. Luckily, I landed on my side and not head first into the coral. There was a bit of bark missing off the ribs and arms but nothing too major. Certainly, it would be some time before I left the relative safety of the deeper water to paddle in over the shallow part of the reef for another set wave. If you haven't hit rock (or reef) bottom in a while, it can be tempting to take a little more risk than you would usually allow yourself to wager. Below, Eric takes a look at the investment waters. The surface may appear to be relatively calm, but what's underneath is razor sharp and the swells are rising... --- Advertisement --- Double Your Money at LEAST 12 Times in 12 Months Options are an exceptional way to make money in volatile markets. Whether the market goes up or down makes no difference... as long as there is movement, there are profits to be had. Let us show you step by step how you too could be soaking up gains of astonishing percentages... like 898%... 529%... even 1,202%. Options Hotline: http://www.agora-inc.com/reports/OHL/EOHLFC07 ------------------------- "Free Diving" Isn't Free By Eric J. Fry On October 12, 2002, a beautiful, 28-year old French woman named Audrey Mestre attempted a record-setting "no limits" free dive to a depth of 561 feet. She succeeded in diving to 561 feet, but not in re-surfacing alive. Today, many investors are diving headlong into high-risk stocks and bonds...and we would not be surprised if these "no limits" investment plunges also end badly. When bi-pedal, oxygen-breathing mammals descend 500-feet below the surface of the sea on a single breath of air, bad things can happen. And bad things can also happen when greedy or naïve mammals descend into the murky depths of high-risk securities. We would readily admit that "buying risk" has paid off nicely for the past couple of years. In fact, in several past editions of the Rude Awakening we had suggested buying the stocks and bonds of countries like Russia and Brazil. We have not abandoned our long-term faith in these two economies. But, in general, we think the time is fast- approaching to "sell risk," rather than to buy it. Since the dawn of the new millennium, risky assets like emerging markets stocks and bonds, U.S. junk bonds and U.S. small caps have greatly outdistanced their less-risky counterparts. Over the past three years, for example, the S&P 500 has gained a respectable 50%. But over the same time-frame, the Russell 2000 Index of small-cap stocks has doubled, and the Morgan Stanley Index of emerging market stocks has tripled. Fear and Complacency: Fear Bear Market Risk-taking has also excelled in the global bond markets. Debt securities from traditionally high-risk borrowers like Russia and Brazil have racked up enviable returns, while U.S. Treasurys have produced almost no return at all. As these various risky assets have dazzled and amazed, the perception of risk in the capital markets has dwindled to almost nothing. You could say, therefore, that fear is in a bear market. "You can almost see it in the marketplace," observes James Grant, editor of Grant's Interest Rate Observer. "Stock- market volatility, as measured by the VIX Index, is at 10- year lows. Credit spreads – investment-grade, speculative- grade, emerging market, etc. – are hugely compressed. Observing the levels, one would almost suppose that the nation was at peace, the yield curve was positively sloped, the H5N1 strain of bird flu had been eradicated and the chairmanship of the Federal Reserve Board was not changing hands..." One might also suppose that Iran had decided to build tractors, instead of reactors...or that the suicide-bombing terrorist groups of the Middle East had taken up new hobbies, like quilting and stamp-collecting. But the modern-day world does not feature such blissful and serene conditions, as evidenced by the array of anti- terrorist squads and NYPD K-9 units that continuously patrol the streets of Wall and Broad, just outside your editor's office window. Curiously, Grant notes, "theses echoes of September 11 do not penetrate the financial district office towers. Inside, computer screens trace out the lows in stock-market volatility and bargain-basement prices in credit default swaps." In other words, most professional market participants are fearless – or complacent – or fearless and complacent, which amounts to a kind of recklessness. Not only do they fear no evil within the financial markets, but they eagerly sell insurance against it. For example, many hedge funds have embraced the business of "writing insurance" against credit defaults – a practice known as selling credit- default swaps. Fear and Complacency: Very, Very High Complacency If the mere mention of "credit default swaps" perplexes you, or causes your eyes to glaze over, don't worry about it. (Your editor only pretends to like this stuff). The essential thing to understand is that these swaps illustrate the price of insurance in the bond market, and therefore, the level of fear or complacency that investors are exhibiting. At the moment, swap prices are very, very low, which means that fear is also very, very low...and complacency is very, very high. (That's rarely a good thing).
Sign Up for The Rude Awakening Start your mornings off with a dose of Rude news. The Rude Awakening is dedicated to highlighting phenomena in the financial markets that others may not see. Let the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times "break news." Sign up FREE Today! We will not share your email address with anyone else, period. -Andrew Palmer, Director E-commerce Marketing We Value Your Privacy |
Default swaps on Russian government debt, for example, have tumbled to record-low levels. Ten years of insurance against a Russian credit default costs a mere 84 basis points. For perspective, as recently as 2001, Russian credit-default swaps cost ten times as much. But back then, the memory of the 1998 Russian credit-default was fresh in the minds of investors, as was the Asian currency crisis of 1997, the Brazilian crisis of 1999 and the Argentinean crisis of 2001. But because the years since 2001 failed to produce a noteworthy financial crisis, bond market participants have learned to turn a blind eye to risk. "Brazil's borrowing costs dropped to a record low earlier this month," Bloomberg News reports, "Investors demand [only] 2.95 percentage points more yield to hold Brazil's 12.25 percent bond due 2030 instead of a U.S. Treasury of comparable maturity, down from 4.48 percentage points in October...Russia's dollar-denominated bonds yield an average of 1.13 percentage points more than U.S. Treasury's with a couple maturity..." 
The U.S. stock market displays a similarly striking absence of fear. The VIX Index of implied option volatility languishes near all-time lows. Because the VIX is based on real-time option prices, it reflects investors' consensus view of future expected stock market volatility. "During periods of financial stress, which are often accompanied by steep market declines," the CBOE Website explains, "option prices - and VIX - tend to rise. The greater the fear, the higher the VIX level. As investor fear subsides, option prices tend to decline, which in turn causes VIX to decline. 
Fear and Complacency: The Balance Between Risk and Reward Eighteen months ago, buying risk seemed like a decent idea. In several editions of the Rude Awakening, for example, we extolled the virtues of Brazilian and Russian stocks and bonds. Twelve months ago, we still loved these markets. Nine months ago, we still liked them a whole bunch. But we like them less now...at least for the short-term. The balance between risk and reward has shifted dramatically away from the buyers of risky assets to the sellers of them. Most risky assets are simply offering too small a return in exchange for the hazards they impose. So while there may be no urgency to sell high-risk assets, we would not argue with the idea. Although the perception of risk protection in the financial markets has fizzled, risk itself remains. It never disappears completely, even if it does sometimes take lengthy sabbaticals. And the presence of risk in the marketplace – both geopolitical and financial - poses ever greater potency and risk, due to the fact that so many investors have been increasing their exposure to it. "Professional investors could protect themselves by buying a portfolio of credit default swaps or an index on stock- price volatility," Grant advises. "Amateurs could lay in Treasury bills." Aggressive amateurs could seek to profit from the return to rising risk awareness – and the commensurate rise in risk premiums – by investing in a fund like Access Flex Bear High Yield Fund. This innovative mutual fund, according to its Website, "seeks to provide inverse (opposite) exposure to the overall high yield market. That means that unlike traditional high yield mutual funds, Access Flex Bear High Yield Fund generally should increase in value when the high yield market falls—and generally should decrease in value when the high yield market rallies." Interestingly, ProFund's Access Flex Bear High Yield (AFBIX) buys credit-default swaps to gain positive returns as junk-bond indexes plunge. Maybe that's a plunge worth taking...from the short side. [Joel's Note: Even sectors that are enjoying a major bull trend are becoming extremely volatile of late. One need only look as far as the commodities and the massive price swings of sugar. This is bad news for anyone who suffers from motion sickness...and great news for Kevin Kerr. This man thrives in a volatile market and he can help you navigate your way to the massive profits that such a climate can yield. Learn how to have Kevin make money for you right here: Thriving on risky business http://www.agora-inc.com/reports/RTA/ERTAFB23 --- Advertisement --- Your second chance at a Billionaire-Backed Miracle Buffett already has over $300 million in this company... it's one of the biggest in his portfolio, even though it's hardly a household name... and buying it now is like buying into Berkshire nearly 40 years ago! It's truly the ONLY stock you'll need to own over the next 10 years... Find out more... http://www.agora-inc.com/reports/FST/EFSTG101 ------------------------- And the Markets...
| Monday | Friday | This week | Year-to-Date | DOW | 10,798 | 10,794 | 5 | 0.8% | S&P | 1,265 | 1,264 | 1 | 1.3% | NASDAQ | 2,259 | 2,263 | -4 | 2.4% | 10-year Treasury | 4.54 | 4.53 | 1.00 | 14.00 | 30-year Treasury | 4.62 | 4.63 | -1.00 | 8.00 | Russell 2000 | 728 | 724 | 4 | 8.1% | Gold | $569.80 | $568.90 | $0.90 | 10.2% | Silver | $9.73 | $9.74 | -$0.01 | 10.3% | CRB | 343.25 | 345.90 | -2.65 | 3.4% | WTI NYMEX CRUDE | $65.02 | $65.37 | -$0.35 | 6.5% | Yen (YEN/USD) | JPY 119.02 | JPY 118.86 | -0.16 | -0.9% | Dollar (USD/EUR) | $1.1964 | $1.2022 | 58 | -1.1% | Dollar (USD/GBP) | $1.7476 | $1.7621 | 145 | -1.6% |
|